Jared Kaplan, CEO of Indigo

    Why Medical Malpractice Is the Best Boring Industry to Disrupt | Jared Kaplan, CEO of Indigo

    Watch this episode

    What did Jared Kaplan, CEO of Indigo teach us?

    1. 01

      Boring, slow-moving industries are often the best targets for startups because legacy processes rely on outdated paperwork and weeks of delay.

    2. 02

      You can radically improve risk pricing by replacing a handful of static variables with 1,500 data points to evaluate physicians.

    3. 03

      Automating data collection and underwriting workflows allows a lean team of five underwriters to process 12,000 policy submissions a year.

    4. 04

      Winning in a trust-heavy market requires securing buy-in from brokers, physicians, and established partners like the AMA Insurance Agency rather than relying on tech alone.

    5. 05

      Addressing nuclear verdicts and rising malpractice claims requires modern underwriting models that price risk accurately instead of penalizing entire specialties.

    Lessons summarized from the YouTube episode description, not a full transcript or verbatim quotes.

    More about Jared Kaplan, CEO of Indigo

    What is this episode about?

    Description from the original YouTube episode.

    Medical malpractice insurance still runs on 15-page paper applications and weeks-long quote times. Jared Kaplan, CEO of Indigo, is rebuilding it with AI.

    On this episode of Care Shift, Jared breaks down why he goes after the most “boring” industries, how Indigo underwrites physicians using 1,500 data points instead of the industry’s usual four, and how five underwriters handle 12,000 submissions a year. We also get into building trust with brokers and physicians, Indigo’s partnership with AMA Insurance Agency, bringing on Town Hall Ventures in the Series B, nuclear verdicts, and where malpractice insurance is headed over the next five years.

    Before Indigo, Jared helped scale OppFi into a public company and built an insurance company earlier in his career. Indigo was incubated with Rubicon Founders.

    Timestamps 00:00 Intro 00:38 Why boring industries are the best place to build 01:30 Why start Indigo instead of partnering with incumbents 03:35 Working with Rubicon Founders from day one 05:12 Lending vs. malpractice insurance: what carries over 08:20 The advantage of coming from outside healthcare 11:01 Trusting AI with million-dollar policies 14:37 Is AI a bubble? Jared’s take 18:13 What the first model got wrong 19:57 One submission on launch day: the trust problem 21:49 Keeping control and building the right board 25:35 What he’d change in the first 90 days 26:48 Lux: underwriting without an application 29:20 The status quo vs. Indigo’s workflow 32:05 The AMA Insurance Agency partnership 33:14 Distribution in a trust-driven market 37:53 How hospitals and physicians see ROI 39:26 Where the Series B capital is going 41:06 Earning an A- AM Best rating 41:52 Why not raise more in an oversubscribed round 42:47 Startup or carrier: Indigo’s balance sheet 44:14 Indigo and malpractice five years out 44:49 Nuclear verdicts and the malpractice crisis 47:59 Rapid fire 52:01 Closing

    Connect with Jared Kaplan LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jared-kaplan-683412/

    Learn more about Indigo Website: https://www.getindigo.com/ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/indigompl/

    Care Shift is a podcast about healthcare AI, robotics, and physical AI, hosted by Sathvik Bilakanti. Browse all episodes or read more about the show.